Subscribe: Comments for notebookeleven
Added By: Feedage Forager Feedage Grade A rated
Language: English
comment  democracy  departed quantities  ghosts departed  heads  line  matt  molecular revolution  people  thoughts  war heads  war  working 
Rate this Feed
Rate this feedRate this feedRate this feedRate this feedRate this feed
Rate this feed 1 starRate this feed 2 starRate this feed 3 starRate this feed 4 starRate this feed 5 star

Comments (0)

Feed Details and Statistics Feed Statistics
Preview: Comments for notebookeleven

Comments for notebookeleven

notes and thoughts in philosophy

Last Build Date: Tue, 24 Apr 2018 04:14:58 +0000


Comment on What I do as a sorcerer by Tom

Tue, 24 Apr 2018 04:14:58 +0000

Great write-up, thank you. I came to it from another spot, on a long journey searching for a meaningful way to embody the grief associated with ecocide and extinction. But your work speaks to some half-baked thoughts I've had about the role of art and intention more broadly.

Comment on What I do as a sorcerer by notebooker

Wed, 07 Mar 2018 10:46:23 +0000

Will, Desire and Belief, themes for another piece, although more likely one that would be on than here I expect, this was written for a non-magical audience and so is framed for that as well. I'd be interested to chat some more on 'Will' with you though.

Comment on What I do as a sorcerer by Paul Newman

Tue, 06 Mar 2018 20:39:15 +0000

Thanks for this, Matt! Would love to hear more of your thoughts on will and belief.

Comment on Reading ‘A Thousand Plateaus’ #1 – ‘rhizome, root and radicle’ by notebooker

Wed, 18 Oct 2017 14:11:14 +0000

A useful note on the problem of translating 'agencement' as 'assemblage' over here: There's also the curious drawings of Marc Ngui over here:

Comment on ATP reading notes 2 – the first 4 principles of the rhizome by patricio

Sun, 15 Oct 2017 15:20:52 +0000

thanks for posting this series!! muchas gracias!!

Comment on The ghosts of departed quantities by What did Newton mean by "Ghosts of Departed Quantities" | Physics Forums - The Fusion of Science and Community

Mon, 12 Jun 2017 03:51:28 +0000

[…] answer is here: The ghosts were the infinitesimals used in Calculus which disappear in the limit.   […]

Comment on Some thoughts on democracy and the death of Tony Benn by Matt

Sat, 06 Dec 2014 23:04:24 +0000

Yeah this was bad news. A bone fide statesman who cared about people. Great to read some of your history with the big man. I wanted to be a bit critical with this one. A freer democracy is achievable, for sure, along the lines you note. It always seems achievable once the dual problems of the politically uneducated masses and the incredible power of those with influence over them have been seen as simple rational calculations that any reasonable person can figure out. I don't know what kind of value fits here, but I don't trust this (mainstream left-wing) line of argument that says we simply educate. I don't know what 'we' means, anyway. Now, I'd wager the corruption of democracy is set within the terms of the debate. An extreme example, but one that could have an immediate response: A politicised group of people decide the details of their working conditions, but never ask why they are working. This second issue is not a political question because it isn't sensible; democracy as decision making, whether in centralised or localised governments, just is conservative by nature. I think this is just because making 'important decisions' rules out decisions that aren't deemed important. I think why we work is a terribly important question. And of course democracy is conservative because of the need for consensus, and which might be bad for more reasons than this (recalling Nietzsche). You write "How might we tell when we have imposed on others our own decisions rather than communicated with them to make a decision? When they revolt, when they resist, when they rebel." - but communicating with people is just the way that they accept violence without resisting. So as long as we 'communicate' and cooperate and make decisions together, I reckon we're non the wiser. I'd much rather people be directly imposed upon and then have a chance to rebel! That to me seems safer (if less safe for 'we' and 'us', whoever they are). I'm also vaguely aware that when I speak for myself it is often someone speaking for me, so what chance do we have to be authentic in any case? I'd also hate politics to have 'my voice' in there somewhere. Gives me a shudder.

Comment on The class war in our heads by Matt

Wed, 03 Dec 2014 15:11:06 +0000

It seems that history had determined that 'working class struggle', or whatever it was, as something very real to me but utterly unclear and attacked on all sides. Workerism never even began to take root with me, ignorant and harmful as working class people often are (not in terms of their redeemable behaviour, that is, just in terms of who - what - they 'are'). So there was the war against the immediate, the look, taste and smell of life. Wanting to 'drop in' to society was always a cop-out; when I started hearing grey people talking about 'opportunities for young people' in the 90s I knew it was a betrayal of how anybody poor actually felt. And yet this weak line is the one people adapted themselves to and continue with today. As long as they reinterpret themselves as potentially happy as long as they have the right values, they are content (and touchy!). Very religious self-betrayal. And the politician-businessmen aren't very good priests, after all. It just speaks to the demand for righteousness no matter the cost (i.e. that your family will always be poor, but the 'biggest adult' has their consolation), and the fear of any large task that real politics would demand. Learning to be more intellectual, which meant initially reading a couple of books, through to fumbling through a BA and MA Philosophy, meant that I encountered the betraying class - the middle class - as a neophyte of its order. Having had no real issue in those years accepting the kind of speaking and thinking required of being a smart member of society, as I grew more it seemed to be very heavily invested in walking a thin line of 'reasonableness' - an unreasonable amount of reasonableness, I suppose. It is the sickly sweet, cooperative, explain anything away nature of the voices, faces, gestures and impostures of the middle class that makes me very sick to look and to listen at them. The ethical line never felt OK that one should simply never take any action unless following some line of authority. Or in fact that all moral virtue is expressed in charity toward others. Given that the upper classes always needed the guillotine meant that there was no 'working class'-ness to care about, no intellectual way out (of the betrayal of the working class), and a country that needed destroying before it could be rebuilt. Political? I have ended up being apolitical, although I still have in my brain all the 'critical' voices of the left-wing books and media I have ever read. At the moment I choose to ignore those voices as being beside the point. Whether people need to learn the standard political, cultural, economic critiques (or be comfortable expressing facsimilies of them) in order to ward off the crushing conservatism and economic, psychological superstitions of our times, I'm really not sure. In fact I feel like there is not time to do this, no time to educate and to learn (whilst always giving that false middle-class sense of self). There is no Zizek-style radical revolutionary warrior that needs to be awakened in each of us (for our own benefit) - Zizek and others have no idea just how bad everything actually is. If he, if the left-wing intelligentsia knew, just one account of a portion of a life, it would amount to more sorrow than is contained in any historical referent of the same, and force them out of study. So Matt yes, I agree, there is a class war in our heads, but only if our heads are not our heads, our thoughts not our own and our feelings needing more than redescription - by Freudian theory, by schizoanalysis etc. In fact they need that performativity, that access to absolute action that is not social that is called upon by schizoanalysis. There are definitely weapons out there - but piecemeal ones. It [...]

Comment on The class war in our heads by matt

Sat, 29 Nov 2014 20:55:32 +0000

I'm reconnecting with your writing and musings Matt. After a short stint in the teaching profession I'm undertaking, finally, my philosophical journey. I was a 'thatcher child', as the phrase goes, new town council-estate raised casualty of war. Put another way, I knew I was in deep shit from the start. I avoid saying 'from an early age' because doesn't that imply that there is some horizon of mastery that I could theoretically acquire, or be later analysed to resolve my pain with? No I was simply in the middle of a class war. But how to express the terms of all this? class war is such a clumsy term... on mobile, more later