Subscribe: Comments on: Children Taken from Couple Over Breast-Feeding Photo
Added By: Feedage Forager Feedage Grade B rated
Language: English
breast  case  child  dallas  feeding  information  made  nude  observer  police department  police  requirements statute  richardson police 
Rate this Feed
Rate this feedRate this feedRate this feedRate this feedRate this feed
Rate this feed 1 starRate this feed 2 starRate this feed 3 starRate this feed 4 starRate this feed 5 star

Comments (0)

Feed Details and Statistics Feed Statistics
Preview: Comments on: Children Taken from Couple Over Breast-Feeding Photo

Comments on: Children Taken from Couple Over Breast-Feeding Photo

believe nothing...

Last Build Date: Tue, 25 Jul 2017 01:36:35 +0000


By: Cliona

Sun, 19 Dec 2004 10:17:44 +0000

This is incredible! A child feeding at it's mother's breast. What could be more normal? Thankfully I live in the free world and not in the US. Cliona

By: Elizabeth

Thu, 11 Dec 2003 19:31:23 +0000

All that information included in the police response was actually in the Dallas Observer article. I don't think the article exaggerated at all; I think this case is absolutely outrageous.

By: ymatt

Thu, 24 Apr 2003 04:17:29 +0000

By the way, here's the response to the email I sent to the Richardson Police Department. Not _completely_ satisfying, but certainly it seems like a whole lot of review was done before the couple was arrested. The Dallas Observer isn't actually the most reputable paper around, so it doesn't entirely surprise me that they might exaggerate a bit. -- Thank you for your note to Officer Spigelmyer regarding this case, as it allows me to provide some additional information that I believe you should be aware of. Facts to keep in mind are: This was not based on a single photo, but on nine.Three of which included the two adults nude on a bunkbed. The nude photos of the adults are obviously sexual in nature. Taken then in totality with the pictures of the nude children, made for a stronger case. The so called breast feeding photograph, very grainy, poor quality in the Observer was actually a very clear color photgraph. The mother is on her knees, the child is standing and "feeding" off the left breast. The child is 1 year of age and by the parent's own admission, had not breast fed since he was two months old. We did not rush to judgement in this case. We followed established referral procedures in response to an outside individual/business (clerk at the Eckerds photo lab) who was concerned enough to call the police. No arrest was made on the initial call. The photos were seized and a report made. A Richardson Police Detective reviewed the report and the photos and conferred with Child Protective Services. CPS made a review and the next day made the case a "priority one" and requested our assistance in removing the children. A judge viewed the evidence and supported the CPS decision. RPD found other nude photos at the home (e.g. child nude on beach) and did not believe that they constituted child pornography. In other words a nude photograph in and of itself is not immediatley labeled as pornography. However, the original nine taken in totality made what we believed was a case that met the requirements of the statute. Also we asked the residents if they had other photographs and did not "toss" their home as the Observer stated to obtain them. We conferred with the District Attorney's Office and they believed this case met the requirements of the statute. At this point no arrests were made but we believed and the D.A. agreed we had probable cause.This being the case we then referred this matter to the Dallas County Grand Jury (a cross section of citizens from all of Dallas County) who reviewed the evidence and agreed it met the requirements of the statute. After these series of checks and balances had taken place Ms. Mercardo and Mr. Fernandez were arrested. The D.A. then dropped the case after they were contacted by the Dallas Observer. When a citizen makes a complaint about such a sensitive issue as child pornography/child abuse, we have to be very careful in how we respond. Does society want only the police to investigate such issues. No, this is the resemblance of a police state. Our officers have to be very careful regarding the amount of discretion they exercise in such matters. The officers in this incident, in taking all the known facts at the time, believed it in the best interest to pursue additional information before proceding further. Therefore, we called upon other social and legal agencies to review and assist. The Richardson Police Department in so doing, has been both responsive and responsible to our community. I hope this information has been helpful. Danny Martin Sergeant-Public Information Officer Richardson Police Department

By: a_stupid_box

Tue, 22 Apr 2003 03:24:42 +0000

Sorry, but you don't count, ymatt -- it's obvious from the fact that you can write that you're not originally from texas. :D

By: ymatt

Tue, 22 Apr 2003 03:05:46 +0000

If it makes anyone feel any better, Texas resident ymatt has written an upset letter to the Richardson Police Department. We'll see if I get a response.

By: Himbi

Mon, 21 Apr 2003 23:01:22 +0000

"Congratulations" to your Taliban Regime in Texas ! It just shows how degenerate authorities across the U.S. have become, all the way up to the top !

By: a_stupid_box

Mon, 21 Apr 2003 12:29:51 +0000

Whoa, that's nuts. My family has tons of pictures of my little brother an I in nothing but our birthday suits in our pre-walking years. A few of my mother breast-feeding as well. In fact, a few years ago my family put up a collage of all the baby pictures we had -- and honestly more than half were naked. My brother, myself, and our parents. It was more a comical/reflective piece to remind us of our innocense and our roots. Whenever anyone looks at it they get a bit red in the face, but it's one of those things that reinforces the idea that you're all family. If I ever have kids (and it's okay with their mother) I intend to add their pictures, clothing or none. People wonder why I have a problem with Texans, and every year, without fail, they give me something to point to.