Subscribe: RealClearPolitics - Articles - Ahmed Humayun
Added By: Feedage Forager Feedage Grade C rated
Language: Swahili
army  establishment sharia  establishment  law  mma  musharraf  pakistan  power religious  power  religious law  religious  sharia law  sharia 
Rate this Feed
Rate this feedRate this feedRate this feedRate this feedRate this feed
Rate this feed 1 starRate this feed 2 starRate this feed 3 starRate this feed 4 starRate this feed 5 star

Comments (0)

Feed Details and Statistics Feed Statistics
Preview: RealClearPolitics - Articles - Ahmed Humayun

RealClearPolitics - Articles - Ahmed Humayun

Last Build Date: Sat, 28 Apr 2007 00:29:33 -0600

Copyright: Copyright 2007

The Hasbah Bill in NWFP: The Beginning of the "Talibanization" of Pakistan?

Sat, 28 Apr 2007 00:29:33 -0600

This is a troubling scenario. However, it neglects an understanding of the arrangements of military and political power in Pakistan. There are countervailing electoral and institutional factors that militate against the establishment of Sharia law. Though the MMA is certainly adept at organizing disruptive rallies and engaging in bellicose rhetoric, its grassroots appeal is limited. Despite the electoral successes enjoyed by the MMA in the 2002 elections, the mainstream political parties--the Pakistan People's Party and the Pakistan Muslim League-- collected more than twice the vote nationally. They oppose the MMA's agenda within the provincial and national assemblies.

To be sure, though national establishment of Sharia law is unlikely, it could be argued that given the MMA's success within NWFP a regionalized establishment of religious law is possible. This argument has some merit. The Pakistani government's writ does not extend to portions of NWFP and Baluchistan, both provinces that border chronically unstable Afghanistan. Al Qaeda and Taliban militants hide out here and cross over into Afghanistan and plan terrorist attacks there and in Pakistan. The presence of these elements means there is scope for informal, extra-constitutional implementation of some form of local Sharia law. This in itself is a worrying possibility that does not respond to easy solutions.

Nevertheless, whatever the strengths of the fanatical elements, it is at best restricted to small portions of the Pakistani territory. Therefore, the nation-wide implementation of religious law is a very distant possibility. Even if Musharraf is overthrown by way of a coup, his replacement will be another general who has risen through the ranks of the army and is devoted to the protection of the army's privileges. The army's tentacles dig deep into the unelected civilian and military bureaucracies that run Pakistan. As an institution it desires the maintenance and extension of its formidable political and economic privileges, not the realization of an obscure religious ideology. Therefore, a successor to Musharraf would be equally unwilling to cede genuine power to the religious parties. This wariness of the religious agenda is likely to persist even if a potential replacement is more sympathetic to the cause of the MMA than an adamantly secular dictator like Musharraf.

Pakistan has undergone this particular experiment before. In the 1980s General Zia, a personally fervent Islamist, promised to create an Islamic state organized around Sharia law. However, aside from a few provisions relating to family law, the vast body of law was untouched and the establishment of an Islamist legal order never came to pass. In other words, Zia did not change the legal structures of the state nor cede any power to the religious clerics.

The lessons of Zia's tenure are that the Pakistani army zealously guards its dominance no matter who rules the roost. It will not voluntarily cede power to clerics which is what Sharia law necessitates. In turn, the MMA does not have nearly enough popular support to pull off a revolutionary transfer of state authority (as happened in Iran in 1979). Thus while the Hasbah bill is a troubling reminder of how Islamic extremism is alive and well in Pakistan, as long as the army remains the overwhelmingly dominant institution in the country, the nation-wide establishment of Sharia law remains a chimera.