Subscribe: Comments on Agency: Past, Present, Future.
http://www.clicknothing.com/click_nothing/2010/10/agency-past-present-future/comments/atom.xml
Added By: Feedage Forager Feedage Grade B rated
Language:
Tags:
agency  ebb flow  fallout new  fallout  game  gameplay  games  gaming  high agency  high  make  new vegas  new  video gaming  video 
Rate this Feed
Rate this feedRate this feedRate this feedRate this feedRate this feed
Rate this feed 1 starRate this feed 2 starRate this feed 3 starRate this feed 4 starRate this feed 5 star

Comments (0)

Feed Details and Statistics Feed Statistics
Preview: Comments on Agency: Past, Present, Future.

Comments on Agency: Past, Present, Future.





Updated: 2010-10-08T06:11:34Z

 



Good survey of the issue... but no mention of strategy games? The original high-agency genre?

2013-12-27T18:13:47Z

Good survey of the issue... but no mention of strategy games? The original high-agency genre?

Good survey of the issue... but no mention of strategy games? The original high-agency genre?




Fallout: New Vegas and the Fallout franchise as a whole have relied on high agency to create a rich gameplay....

2010-10-23T23:34:41Z

Fallout: New Vegas and the Fallout franchise as a whole have relied on high agency to create a rich gameplay....

Fallout: New Vegas and the Fallout franchise as a whole have relied on high agency to create a rich gameplay. I think a good measure of high agency is how many players feel compulse to replay the game, and I don't think there's many like Fallout where there's a clear incentive to not only chose different kinds of characters but make different choices which like forks in the road lead to different paths.

I'm not a purist but the argument of agency vs. cinematic experience feels like a mute point, video games cannot out-cinema cinema, so even as some elements from other mediua can lead to innovation in video gaming, what should always be the aim of video gaming is what makes it special, and agency is not something easily found or realized in other digital media, if ever. So while there is a value in improving narrative or adding cinematic effects in video gaming, it should never be at the price of trimming down agency.

This is a great article, I've posted some excerpt on the video game canon ( http://videogamecanon.com ) and I hope more people in the video gaming community will gain some awareness that gameplay does trumendensly benefit from a high level of agency.

Regarding the Fallout series, while I enjoyed playing Fallout 3, I actually had a lot more fun playing Fallout 2, if anything because in the latter, you have a huge influence on the world game: I remember the ability to tore entire cities apart, or the lasting consequence of choosing between different mob gangs, killing certain characters or joining certain leagues... the impact of the player had in Fallout 2 was substantially greater than the one in Fallout 3, and I don't count the number of times I started the game from scratch and took different paths, it was one of the best gaming experience I ever had, and one that is surprisingly hard to find these days.




I hope that games such as Human Revolution will give modern audiences a kick that hasn't existed for a while-...

2010-10-13T05:14:03Z

I hope that games such as Human Revolution will give modern audiences a kick that hasn't existed for a while-...

I hope that games such as Human Revolution will give modern audiences a kick that hasn't existed for a while- games with a high degree of agency that are visually arresting. Fallout: New Vegas has to use its agency and writing to make up for an engine that felt dated in certain paces when it was brand-new.




To make a blatant oversimplification: What we might be seeing here is a general ebb and flow of agency vs....

2010-10-11T07:24:23Z

To make a blatant oversimplification: What we might be seeing here is a general ebb and flow of agency vs....

To make a blatant oversimplification: What we might be seeing here is a general ebb and flow of agency vs. cinematic experience. We used to have games that were all about playing, with little or no story involved. At first, the concepts and game mechanics improved, then story inched its way into games and suddenly, agency had to be turned down somewhat to allow the story bits to shine. And now we've arrived at a point where cinematic experience over gameplay is generally frowned upon, so the next couple of years will establish a standard where story doesn't subvert gameplay but enhances agency in a meaningful way by allowing for player expression and, of course, moral choice. I'm not saying this will be particularly easy, but I'm looking forward to those games. :)




This is the most intelligent thing I've read in some time. Thanks for posting it.

2010-10-09T09:59:03Z

This is the most intelligent thing I've read in some time. Thanks for posting it.

This is the most intelligent thing I've read in some time. Thanks for posting it.




Agency and commercial success are not mutually exclusive, either, as MineCraft is now demonstrating.

2012-07-04T16:13:20Z

Agency and commercial success are not mutually exclusive, either, as MineCraft is now demonstrating.

Agency and commercial success are not mutually exclusive, either, as MineCraft is now demonstrating.