Subscribe: Comments on: Pseudopod 86: The Wild Y
Added By: Feedage Forager Feedage Grade B rated
Language: English
didn  ending  horror story  horror  maybe  pretty  scene  science fiction  sex scene  sex  story  time  twist ending  twist  written 
Rate this Feed
Rate this feedRate this feedRate this feedRate this feedRate this feed
Rate this feed 1 starRate this feed 2 starRate this feed 3 starRate this feed 4 starRate this feed 5 star

Comments (0)

Feed Details and Statistics Feed Statistics
Preview: Comments on: Pseudopod 86: The Wild Y

Comments on: Pseudopod 86: The Wild Y

The Sound of Horror

Last Build Date: Sun, 22 Mar 2015 08:02:35 +0000


By: RoWie

Thu, 23 Oct 2008 12:28:22 +0000

Yea !! This is indeed a great idea for a longer story. I liked it very much. To me it has a 'pulpy' feel, and I like easy to read/listen stories. Whether they're scifi, horror, detective or adventure. Great site by the way. Best of luck from the Netherlands. Roland

By: PK

Thu, 10 Jul 2008 21:34:31 +0000

way to waste a big open-ended idea on a small cheap ending.

By: Sgarre1

Sat, 05 Jul 2008 23:39:50 +0000

I won't waste anyone's time with too much of a "me too" (Continuum is right on the money). Silly, waste of a time story seemingly written with a high-schooler's understanding of gender relations.

Maybe Escape Artist should start a "humor pod" or "frivolity pod" for these kinds of things. Maybe Pseudopod should go to bi-weekly or fill the occasional gap with readings of some older public domain titles.

And, yes, no need to get into the genre shell-game but this, to me, was pure sci-fi with an unhappy ending. And, since I've already (finally) listened to next week's, that one was as well.

I appreciated the shout-out to "The Immortal" television show, though.

Thanks for listening

“The Underground marks its disdain for The Mainstream by referring to it in feminized terms” Peter Shapiro from “Club Culture” review, The Wire # 143, January, 1996


Wed, 11 Jun 2008 18:06:40 +0000

Awesome idea! This could be the basis of a novel!

By: George

Sun, 18 May 2008 01:06:10 +0000

The PERFECT blend of SF/Fantasy/Horror - this deserves exposure on Escape Pod and Podcastle!

By: Dom

Wed, 07 May 2008 02:25:11 +0000

No. Not scary. But it doesn't mean we can't take something out of it. This started as an 8/10, but turned into a 6. What happened?

Eh, I still enjoyed the story, though. I knew all politicians were 60 year old bums. ;)

By: V

Fri, 02 May 2008 20:23:06 +0000

Predictable twist, amusing ending, useless sex scene, flat characters.

Not scary in the slightest. Although I'm a bit out of date, the last one that creeped me out was Votary, which I disliked because of how gross it was while at the same time noticing some interesting workmanship.

By: csrster

Wed, 30 Apr 2008 06:18:33 +0000

Hmm. Not so much "a story with a twist" as an over-lengthy joke. Given the one throw-away line revealing that the incumbent is a Democrat, I'm getting a pretty clear picture as to not merely the gender but the identity of the First Lady in question. To be fair, I suppose discovering you've been genetically transmogrified into Hillary would be pretty horrifying.

By: Abbie

Fri, 25 Apr 2008 05:11:25 +0000

This story didn't quite work for me. I knew a twist was coming. I didn't actually guess it, but I felt disappointed when I realized what had happened. I said, "Was that all?" Like another commented, I find it absurd that a disintegrating, homeless drunk wouldn't be willing to take his chances in a relatively (we assume) fit female body, even if he might have to brain the president to survive. Liver failure is a pretty lousy way to die. I also assumed that the sex was only there to show us that he's heterosexual and will now have gender identity issues. It felt kind of stuffed sideways into the story - an issue that's barely presented and then abandoned.

By: JD

Thu, 24 Apr 2008 20:23:56 +0000

I liked the story, but, yeah, I gotta say, more SF than horror. Plus the sex scene? What was that? Say the twist coming a mile away, just waited to see what it was. But it was still worth the listen!

By: scatterbrain

Thu, 24 Apr 2008 16:51:39 +0000

This should be on Escape Pod.

By: Continuum

Tue, 22 Apr 2008 00:38:25 +0000

Juvenile plot. Pedantic writing. Gratuitous sex scene. Seems that the only worthwhile part was the quote "This isn't even bad science fiction . . . " The true horror was that this story was 15 minutes long.


Tue, 22 Apr 2008 00:36:13 +0000

Yeah, I saw the ending coming about the time it was mentioned (genetically normal) women don't have a Y chromosone. But then I may have read one too many stories with the same ending twist (minus the strangler President.) Plus, it's on the Horror podcast, so it couldn't just end with the actor becoming President.

By: Spiff

Sun, 20 Apr 2008 16:11:40 +0000

I guess I'm the biggest idiot in the room. I know a twist happened at the end of the story, but can anyone explain to me what happened so I can know if it was predictable too? ;) Thanks.

By: Brett

Sat, 19 Apr 2008 16:26:21 +0000

Maybe it's just because I didn't listen to it until I was really tired, but I was very pleasantly surprised by the twist. Since it was short horror fiction, but looked like it was setting up a short science fiction novel, I knew it was going to have to have SOME kind of twist to qualify it for this site, but what the actual twist was didn't occur to me.

As far as your misogyny comment, GrimGnome, I really didn't see it that way. I certainly agree that if someone was offered the choice to think the situation through, and was presented with the choice in the words you use, it would be pretty crazy, and probably sexist, to turn it down. But to look down and suddenly realize your penis is missing would be a pretty traumatic thing for a guy, even worse if he thought fast enough to realize that he could probably not turn back, and at least one or two first ladies had already been killed.

By: GrimGnome

Sat, 19 Apr 2008 14:34:45 +0000

If you can't say something nice... well, then there wouldn't be much written on the internet, right?

The sex scene was clunky and implausible.

The twist ending was extremely obvious. I kept hoping that he'd have to portray a presidential pet, like Nixon's Checker's the Dog.

And OK, isn't the whole premise just a teensy bit silly not to mention misogynistic that a man would prefer being a homeless alcoholic to being a rich and powerful woman?

But heck, I'm still a HUGE Ben Phillips fan. And honestly, I still a pretty big Pseudopod fan.

By: Void Munashii

Sat, 19 Apr 2008 03:44:06 +0000

I enjoyed the story, even if the ending was a bit predictable before the big reveal. The only real criticism I have is that this seems more like a story for EscapePod than a horror story.

By: Brian Deacon

Sat, 19 Apr 2008 00:47:31 +0000

Alright, I'll take the cheap shot:

"This isn't even bad science fiction. It's below that level." -- Paul Toland, The Wild Y

And the kind of nit-picky stuff that I hate seeing on forums, but I'll do it anyway: My math says there would be only a little over 100 people on the planet with this gene if it effects 1 in 30 million males. I think that puts 5 of them in the United States. What are the odds that those 5 people are having their blood undergoing testing that the government could get to?

And this was a silly movie when it was called "Dave".

The non-sequitor sex scene was totally awkward.

Enough kvetching... maybe something a little more thoughtful. Horror has not been my bag, but Pseudopod is making it increasingly so. (Do take that as the large compliment it was intended to be.) But this story seems to suffer from the problem that SF and Fantasy seem less prone to -- an over-reliance on the twist ending. I don't think it's inherent to horror, but I'm beginning to suspect that short horror is maybe more hamstrung by the shortness aspect than the other genres, and so has a more limited list of techniques for making a good story. I don't even have anything against twist endings. It just seems that they get used a lot more in this genre than others. Having said that, I actually hated this story less once I got the twist ending. And furthermore, the story is a heck of a lot better than the zero short stories I have ever written, so let me just go on record as saying that Teej Grant totally kicks my butt. :)

This would be a good segue into the pigeon-holing argument over whether this was more of a horror story or an SF piece. Except that I find that whole line of thought incredibly uninteresting.

Okay, I promise the next time I post, I will be less snarky. I'm still a huge fan. And like Mari, I think Alasdair is the K-Raddiest.

By: Mari Mitchell

Fri, 18 Apr 2008 19:38:33 +0000

. I really liked the title. I thought the story was well written; the words well chosen and why he chose the elements of tale were well done.

The idea behind the tale is not remarkable fresh but the ride nonetheless enjoyable.

The read was perfect!

I liked the ending comments as well. Alasdair is always a delight. To me he looks like a dirty blonde Mel Gibson, but younger and less of a Christian drunk. It’s his playful nature that I find compelling. Although he sounded a tad under the weather.

There was a book about the subject of many personalities not being uncommon, but in fact something we all do. I wish I could recall the title

Although I can see why the new guy have the physical features of the president but why would have all of the same bad habits. I think a great many of them are because of the events we have gone through.

By: ComputerKing

Fri, 18 Apr 2008 12:08:35 +0000

A nice story, but by the time they'd given him the first taste of Wild Y bliss, without confirming his assumptions, I knew something was wrong. I took a guess at the outcome, and I was right.

Well written, Interesting, but a little too predictable at the end. Of course, I've been guilty of the same thing at times...