Subscribe: Comments on: What does the British Government know?
Added By: Feedage Forager Feedage Grade B rated
Language: English
act  civil servant  foi act  foi request  foi requests  foi  government  guy  information  legislation  obvious thing  relevant  things 
Rate this Feed
Rate this feedRate this feedRate this feedRate this feedRate this feed
Rate this feed 1 starRate this feed 2 starRate this feed 3 starRate this feed 4 starRate this feed 5 star

Comments (0)

Feed Details and Statistics Feed Statistics
Preview: Comments on: What does the British Government know?

Comments on: What does the British Government know?

Tech, science, cosplay and news by geeks, for geeks! We make technology sexy!

Last Build Date: Sun, 22 Apr 2018 14:30:48 +0000


By: Guy

Thu, 22 May 2008 12:02:12 +0000

Perhaps just the Department I've been working in for the past 7+ years, then. Granted I've come across my share of shirkers who prefer to avoid answering queries of any kind, but that is largely down to poor management and the FOI Act hasn't changed that. Of all the queries I've had to deal with pitched as FOI requests, none of them have actually met the criteria to be handled as FOI requests and rather have fallen well within the bounds of existing correspondence, with the relevant procedures duly applied. Of course what the FOI act does do is potentially criminalise an individual for making an honest mistake if the information provided turns out to be incorrect. And it requires timescales to be met regardless of whether they are realistic (I recall a trainee gleefully explaining that if a FOI request was handed in to the coastguard at the northern end of the Shetland Islands, the 20 day clock starts ticking at that time, never mind how long it might take to be delivered to the relevant official in the Department in Westminster). Don't get me wrong, I'm all for people understanding that they have the right and indeed the obligation to question the things that go on in government, ostensibly on their behalf. But the FOI act, as with just about any legislation, is a blunt tool that should only be looked to as a last resort. From my experience all it manages to do is make my job harder and I've yet to see an FOI request that actually results in information being released that a normal letter wouldn't have.

By: Mark O'Neill

Thu, 22 May 2008 11:28:44 +0000

Well Guy, you're talking to an ex-British civil servant from Scotland and handing over information to the public and journalists is not an "obvious thing". To my mind, it required a law because my ex-colleagues were extremely reluctant to hand over anything if the public asked for it. Excuses were always thought up, stalling tactics always devised. I left the Scottish Government before the FOI Act came into force so I don't know if the FOI Act has improved anything but I'm sure it hasn't made anything worse.

By: Guy

Thu, 22 May 2008 11:05:33 +0000

What a wonderful way to completely misunderstand things. We haven't had a Freedom of Information act in the UK until recently not because we are a closet, secretive nation cowed by the Official Secrets Act, but rather because there has not been the need to waste the time in enshrining such an obvious thing in law and creating an additional bureaucracy. Frankly the only reasons I can see for us having such a ridiculous piece of legislation now are that: a) the current government greatly enjoys creating new legislation so it can then point to it and say 'look what we have done', regardless of whether it is needed or worthwhile; b) the vast majority of people in this country are far more likely to believe the ill-informed mitherings of the press than to actually engage with government officials and consequently assume that the government is busy doing things in secret; and c) everyone else has one so we must too. /rant Signed, A Slightly Miffed Civil Servant